Review by Eddie AI - Time-stamped feedback on your video frm your team & AI. Free

Thanks so much for the hunt, @thisiskp_

You know how this story goes: we were using a bunch of tools that weren’t great or were overpriced and we thought, what the heck, we can do this better.

And so we did.

Hello, Review by Eddie AI.

We’re an agentic AI video editing co for pros. We make a lot of videos in our team. I have lots and lots of feedback for my team in AI science, software eng, design, and video marketing.

Leaving timestamped comments on a video is not revolutionary.

So why is frame.io so expensive? And so many tools are meh.

This is a tax on video storytelling.

As a team and as a company we are driven to enable more people to tell more and better video stories.

Huddling with your team on the latest version of the edit and to get their feedback on how the cut lands is part of this.

So welcome Review.

It’s free.

And there is a novel twist: you can ask Eddie AI for feedback too. It’s surprisingly good!

Try it and let me know what you think. It's my turn to receive feedback :)

The no-login, no-reupload flow is probably the strongest part here. getting feedback on a cut should be quick, but it often turns into another tool, another upload, version confusion, and scattered notes. as someone working on launch and product videos, turning frame-accurate comments directly into an actionable to-do list sounds genuinely useful :)

The AI reviewer is the part I'd be most curious to test. does Eddie mainly catch objective issues like pacing, dead space, audio, and unclear structure, or can it also understand the intended audience and give more subjective feedback on whether the story actually lands?

Timestamped feedback beats "make it pop" comments in a doc, no contest. I build approval flows for written content and the pattern matches: feedback anchored to the exact spot kills half the revision cycles. Does Eddie's AI feedback ever disagree with the human reviewers, and who wins?

honestly this looks super useful for cutting down interview footage way faster. one thing that would help a lot is being able to save your own custom prompt templates for different types of edits, like a specific style for youtube shorts vs a documentary feel, so you dont have to re explain the tone every single time

honestly the multi cam podcast support sounds great but it would be really useful to have some kind of auto transcription search so i can jump to specific moments in long interviews without scrubbing through the whole timeline

One thing that would make Eddie even more useful for me is multi-language transcript support for interview cuts. Half my interviews are in Spanish and a few in Portuguese, and right now the auto-detect struggles with mixed-language dialogue. Adding a clean way to switch transcription language mid-project (or auto-detect per speaker) would save a ton of cleanup time before the rough cut lands in Premiere.

Hey PH fam 👋

Super excited to bring Eddie Review to the global tech and startup community today.

I hunted Eddie AI’s first version back in October 2024 when they reimagined editing with AI. Today they're going after the part of video production nobody builds for: the feedback loop.

Here's the thing about video work. The cut is never done when the editor says it's done. It's done when the team, the client, and the stakeholders say it's done. That review round-trip is where timelines quietly die. Version 7 in the group chat. Notes like "fix the middle part." A link that expires before the client opens it.

Eddie Review compresses that whole loop into minutes:

→ Share a cut and collect frame-accurate comments, no login or re-upload needed
→ Ask Eddie AI to review your edit before a human ever sees it (this part genuinely surprised me)
→ Every note becomes a to-do list you can actually work through

The AI review is the piece I'd watch closely. It's like having a second pair of editor eyes on your cut at 2am before the client call at 9. You catch the pacing issue yourself instead of hearing about it in the meeting.

And it's free. Not free trial. Just free.

Built by @amdfad @shamirallibhai and the Eddie team, who've been quietly building the full stack of agentic video tools for pros. They're all here today.

Robbie, anyone who has traded muddled notes back and forth on a cut will feel the relief here. Getting feedback to land exactly where it belongs takes so much friction out of the whole thing. Really tidy.

the "ask Eddie to review your edit before a human sees it" part is the feature I'd actually use daily. so much of editing feedback is just catching your own pacing/continuity mistakes before someone else has to point them out, and doing that at 2am before a client call is a real problem worth solving. does the AI review get sharper over time based on what your team actually flags as important vs what it flags, or is it the same generic pass every time regardless of who's on the review?