Review by Eddie AI - Time-stamped feedback on your video frm your team & AI. Free
by•
Eddie Review is the fastest way to get feedback on your cut, in minutes. No login, no re-upload, free. Collect frame-accurate comments from your team, get an AI review of your edit, and turn every note into a to-do list you can act on.
Replies
Any plans for batch/API access? If this could fit into our remote video editor pipeline, that would be epic
Eddie AI
@tahsin_amio Great idea. Totally possible. I'll work on this and DM you soon.
Ota
Congrats on the launch! The extension integrations are what stand out here: meeting editors where they already work rather than asking them to leave their timeline is the right call, and native R3D and BRAW ingestion is a detail that will matter a lot to the people who need it.
Curious how Eddie handles pacing decisions, specifically when there's no script to anchor against. For something like a run-and-gun interview where the story only becomes clear in the edit, how does it decide what to cut versus what to keep?
Eddie AI
@faithada Hey, this is a great point. The way it decides the edit is both using your stated objectives and using its understanding of what makes a good edit, which it has been trained on.
The no-login, time-stamped feedback that becomes a to-do list is exactly the friction I hit sharing cuts with non-editors - they leave vague "the middle drags" notes with no timecode. Day-one question: does a reviewer just open a rendered preview link, or do they need anything installed? And when a note turns into a to-do, does it carry the exact timecode back into Premiere or Resolve so I jump straight to that frame, or is it a separate checklist I have to line up against the timeline myself?
Eddie AI
@leo404 Awesome, thanks. I would say try it out! You don't need anything installed.
thanks, no-install for reviewers is exactly what makes it shareable. The other half I'm still curious about: once a reviewer note becomes a to-do, does it carry the exact timecode back into Premiere or Resolve so I jump straight to that frame, or is it a separate checklist I have to line up against the timeline by hand?
@amdfad Upvoted this today. Free-tier products need the first email to convert fast before people forget why they signed up, curious how that's handled.
Eddie AI
@alex_iliescu Awesome, thanks.
Eddie AI
@alex_iliescu Awesome, man. Thanks so much. Appreciate you.
@fahad good to know, I'll give it a real try this week on an actual project instead of just poking at the demo. does the "sharper over time" part mean it's learning from my specific comment history, or is it more of a general model upgrade that happens for everyone at once?
Eddie AI
@omri_ben_shoham1 Great question. Right now, it's more of a general model over time, but also I'm trying to make it so that it learns from your specific comments, the comments left on your video, and what kind of video style you have. We will share more about this in our next release. Check out Eddie AI.
The no-login, share-with-unlimited-people flow is great for speed, but it also means anyone holding the link can view and comment on your unreleased cut. For agency work on embargoed client content, is there a way to expire or revoke a review link once that round of feedback is collected, or does it stay live indefinitely once it's shared? Feels like the kind of thing that's fine right up until a client's unreleased ad ends up forwarded into the wrong group chat.
Eddie AI
@galdayan Awesome! Thanks! Do try it out and let me know what you think.
Lancepilot
A great product and great fit for video editing in this AI era. looking forward to try and congrats on the launch!
Eddie AI
@istiakahmad thanks man! Appreciate it
Eddie AI
Honestly, this was such a joy to work on!!! We were initially using this internally. We loved iterating on it, making it better, and ultimately sharing it w our video friends -- and we've heard such great things and have seen so many people take advantage of this free review tool that we are now opening it up to the wider community.
I am so, so excited to see how you use it and hear your feedback about how we can make it better! Like Shamir said, feedback is a gift, and making timestamped video comments expensive is a tax on video storytelling, which we definitely want to lift 💪
Eddie AI
Thank you @thisiskp_ for hunting this!!! 💐💐💐
Feedback loops are such an underrated part of the video workflow — most tools focus entirely on creation and leave review as an afterthought (usually a messy Slack thread). Is the AI feedback purely technical (exposure, cuts, pacing) or does it try to assess narrative/messaging too? Curious where you've drawn that line.
I've been waiting for an AI editor that integrates with my existing workflow. One feature I'd love to see is more control over the auto-generated rough cuts, maybe some sliders for adjusting pace and tone. That would make Eddie a game-changer for my team.