General
p/generalShare and discuss tech, products, business, startups, or product recommendations
trending

We deleted the "are you enjoying the app?" screen in front of our rating prompt

The pattern is everywhere and I'd built it without thinking about it. Before the native App Store rating sheet, show your own little screen. Enjoying the app? Happy face goes through to the review sheet. Sad face goes to a feedback form that emails you instead. Every growth writeup calls it a best practice, and it does measurably raise your average rating.
It raises it by making the negative reviews not happen. That's the entire mechanism. You're not collecting more sentiment, you're routing half of it into a private inbox where it can't reach anyone deciding whether to download. Once I'd said that out loud I couldn't keep it.
What replaced it is dumber and I like it much more. Two positive moments an actual save, an actual "this helped" bank a signal. On the second one the native sheet fires directly. No pre-ask, no fork, no branch where I get to decide who's allowed to count. iOS makes the final call on whether the sheet even appears, which I have zero visibility into and have made peace with. Sixty-day cooldown, three prompts lifetime, and if the sheet isn't available on that device the signal stays banked instead of burning a prompt.
Two things I got wrong on the way there. The first pass counted opening the app as a positive moment, which isn't a positive moment, it's a Tuesday it now only counts things the person actively chose to do. The second: the ask initially sat behind a paid surface, so the people most likely to be having a good time were the ones least able to be asked. Moving one of the two signals somewhere freely reachable mattered more than anything I did to the prompt itself.
The part I'm still unsure about: I removed my own read on sentiment and replaced it with nothing. Unhappy people used to land in a form. Now they land in the App Store, or nowhere. Has anyone kept an always-available feedback door open without it quietly turning back into the sad-face branch?

•

4mo ago

Founders: what's the worst interview question you've ever been asked?

I've sat on both sides of a lot of interviews and some questions still puzzle me.

"Are you a leader or a follower?" is my pick. It's a false binary with an obvious right answer, so nobody says "follower" and the interviewer learns nothing. Good people are both depending on the situation, which is the one answer the question doesn't leave room for.

Curious what other people have run into. The ones with no right answer, the brainteasers that measured nothing, the questions that only tested how well you'd rehearsed. Or the opposite, if you've ever been asked something genuinely good that told them something real about you.

•

4mo ago

The hardest problem in AI + finance isn't accuracy — it's trust. Where do you draw the line?

I've been building in the AI-for-finance space, and I've noticed the real barrier isn't whether the models are good enough. They're getting scary good at reading documents, reconciling transactions, spotting patterns a human would miss. The barrier is trust and specifically, the gap between AI that reads your finances and AI that acts on them.

Here's the line I keep bumping into: people are surprisingly comfortable letting an agent categorize expenses or summarize their spending. But the moment it wants to do something file the taxes, move the money, recommend a five-figure decision the comfort evaporates. And I don't think that's irrational. The cost of a wrong email is an awkward apology; the cost of a wrong financial action is real money or an audit.

What's interesting is that the same person will draw that line in totally different places depending on stakes and reversibility. A $40 miscategorization? Whatever, fix it later. A mistimed refi or a missed deduction? Now trust matters enormously.

•

4mo ago

Will AI assistants change how people discover products?

I think product discovery is starting to change.

Before, people searched Google, asked friends, checked communities, or browsed places like Product Hunt to find new tools.

Now more people simply ask AI:

What is the best tool for this?
What should I use instead of this product?
What are the best options for my use case?

•

4mo ago

One conversation changed our roadmap.


We expected users to ask for more features.
Instead, they kept asking for fewer steps to complete the same task.
That changed the way we think about product development. Adding functionality isn t always progress. Sometimes removing friction creates much more value.
Has customer feedback ever completely changed the direction of your product?

A question that completely changed our customer interviews

Early on, we'd ask:

"What features do you want?"

The answers were usually long wish lists.

Then we changed one question:

The hard shift from "perfect code" to "fast shipping": What broke along the way

Hey Product Hunt community!

Coming from an engineering and agency background, our default mindset was always to write clean, fully modular, and perfectly scalable code before pushing anything to production.

However, building our own Micro-SaaS products quickly shattered that mindset.

We learned the hard way that spending weeks over-architecting a feature that users might not even want is the fastest way to waste momentum. Shifting to "shipping fast and listening to user feedback" forced us to make uncomfortable trade-offs between technical debt and speed.

•

4mo ago

What is the last client complaint you got that you wish you had heard sooner?

Most complaints I get are not new. They are old, quiet, and only turn into a complaint once someone finally runs out of patience. By the time I hear it, the person has usually been annoyed for weeks and just never said anything, or said something small that I did not register as a warning. Curious whether that pattern is just me, or whether the actual complaint almost always arrives later than the moment the person first felt it.

•

4mo ago

How many users do you need before you trust your product feedback?

When you re building your first product, it s easy to become too close to the problem. As the creator, you already understand how everything works, so it can be difficult to notice confusing parts of the experience.

That s why testing with other people is so important.

•

4mo ago

What is the client message you told yourself you would answer in five minutes, then did not?

Every one of my businesses has one of these somewhere right now, a message I read, decided was not urgent, and then lost inside everything else that felt more urgent in the moment. By the time I remember it, I cannot always tell if it still needs a fast reply or if the moment already passed. Curious how everyone else catches these before they turn into an apology text. Is it a system, a habit, or mostly luck.

First
Previous
•••
542543544
•••
Next