Stricter Discussions (Forums) on the Product Hunt – Bad or Good?

A few days ago I saw some posts here about:

– the number of discussions is decreasing,

– sometimes they are approved later,

– that there is "other community growth" – I don't know what was meant by that and I'm just guessing.

Yes, the conditions have changed – Forums are more moderated and rules are strict, hoping to bring more value and engagement of active (real) users.

https://help.producthunt.com/en/articles/10478791-product-hunt-forum-guidelines

In general:

• discussion shouldn't be "egocentric" but should invite to be a part of it (actively discuss)

• should bring a value – something to learn, find out

• shouldn't be replicable – not something, that can be easily found on the internet

= It should result in quality and genuine discussion with interactions.

I also find it harder to come up with a new topic that is unique while sticking to the rules, but I assume it raises the bar.

How do you perceive this updated Forum format and its new rules?

Just a few quick tips to create discussions that have a chance to be shared:

• Ask questions: Opinions, experiences, lessons learned.

• React to news, new situations in the world, and discuss current events.

• Follow up on other people's forums, referencing their questions that prompted other questions.

• Talk about products, their gaps, improvements, and useful use-cases. (That's what product forums are for.)