Fair compensation for interns – what’s your take?
On June 14, 2023, the European Parliament officially voted to ban unpaid internships.
This honestly made me happy, because I remember how, during college, I was expected to spend a full 2 months working full-time at an advertising agency as an unpaid intern (Spoiler alert: I fought for and got some pay 😀), but that wasn’t the norm.
Most interns didn’t get paid at all.
I get that students are sometimes, sorry for the phrasing, "not worth compensating" because they’re there to learn and gain know-how. On the other hand, it’s still about people investing their time, which should be rewarded in some way.
What’s your opinion on paid vs. unpaid internships? Which side are you on?
And what do you think is appropriate compensation?
193 views


Replies
Inbox Agents - Intelligent Unified Inbox
minimalist phone: creating folders
@cam_mcmaster1 I understand this, tho I think that companies will rather use AI than interns (and most "intended-interns" will try to use AI to make their own solution. Maybe this is the future that awaits us.
Inbox Agents - Intelligent Unified Inbox
minimalist phone: creating folders
@cam_mcmaster1 yes, they can have some experience, but the question is whether they will be needed in the company. It will have only a "pro forma" of helping some students.
@cam_mcmaster1 exactly
Not paying interns is patently exploitive. In some industries - fashion and media come to mind - it's endemic.
A top 3 ad agency had me come in and do in-service training to their stockade of unpaid graphic artists who were summer vacation substitutes for highly paid full-timers. That's a scam for clients who get mediocre works, for the vendors who had are expected to catch intern screwups, and for the interns themselves who are expected to perform miracles for the promise of experience.
We pay a modest hourly wage - at the moment $15/hour. We mentor interns extensively, including performance expectations and reviews. Showing up clear-headed and on time is at the top of the list.
Inbox Agents - Intelligent Unified Inbox
minimalist phone: creating folders
@rtinfow Yeah, but there are 2 opposites: Interns who are really skilful and ambitious and interns who just sit in the place. I think that one deserves pay, but the other one just takes it like an activity just because of fulfilling some duty towards the school (we had to undergo some internship to earn our degree).
Inbox Agents - Intelligent Unified Inbox
The best pay for interns is the time devoted to them by experienced professionals under whom they learn the things.
When i started my learning journey, we used to get 45 dollars per month (in India) which might be equivalent to say 200-300 dollars people make in US.
It's the time of seniors that we get to work with.
They were industry experts since 12-15 years. We get to learn straight from them to be an expert in that field in say 4-5 years or so.
minimalist phone: creating folders
@ca_rajesh_pabari Okay, that's fair. I also got like 300 euros per month, but it usually covered only my stay in the town, where I got accommodation for the internship purposes. If I did it for free, I would probably had to pay rent (from nothing).
Lancepilot
I’m all for paid internships. Interns do real work and invest time fair compensation isn’t just nice, it’s necessary. Even a modest stipend makes opportunities accessible and shows respect for their effort. Unpaid internships shouldn’t be the norm anymore.
minimalist phone: creating folders
@priyankamandal IMO, such students are even more likely to put more effort into the work.
TinyCommand
We’ve always had paid interns for a simple reason.
We don’t hire interns unless we genuinely believe they can add value. And in the few cases where that hasn’t worked out, we’ve had an honest conversation early and asked them to move on.
Not because they weren’t capable, but because it’s better for everyone. They get the chance to find work they actually enjoy and can contribute to, and we avoid stretching both sides in the name of “learning.”
For me, it comes down to this :
If we expect someone to deliver value, we should pay them.
If they’re not in a position to contribute yet, they deserve clarity rather than free labor masked as “experience.”
minimalist phone: creating folders
@priyanka_gosai1 This is how it should work. What was the selection process?
TinyCommand
@busmark_w_nika For us, it starts with clarity.
Before hiring anyone, intern or full time, we clearly define what they will work on and who will guide them. If we cannot answer those two things, we do not hire.
Even for interns, we look for some prior exposure in the same role. For example, a development intern is expected to have basic coding experience. The same applies to marketing and other roles. An internship can be a space to explore, but it should also reflect a willingness to learn and deliver.
Our internships usually run for at least three months. This gives enough time to train well and also allows the intern to contribute meaningfully. If within the first couple of weeks it feels like the role is not the right fit, it is better for both sides to move on, and that is completely okay.
This approach has worked well for us and for the interns who have grown with the team.
minimalist phone: creating folders
@priyanka_gosai1 So do they do any assignments before being approved, right?
TinyCommand
@busmark_w_nika mostly yes...we give them a case study type problems to solve depending on the role.
I’m fully in favor of paid internships.
Unfortunately, in India, there are still no strong laws that protect interns from being unpaid. I really hope that changes and soon.
The common justification is, “You’re here to learn, so we don’t pay.”
But in reality, interns are often given heavy, repetitive tasks that full-time employees don’t want to do, and they’re expected to do it for free. That’s not learning, that’s exploitation.
Yes, interns gain skills and exposure. But they’re also putting in real effort, real time, and contributing real work. Any form of compensation even a modest stipend signals respect for that value.
It boosts morale, improves productivity, and helps interns feel like they actually matter to the organization.
This is not just an India problem.
Across many developing countries, unpaid internships are normalized under the excuse of experience or certification, and it takes a real toll on how young professionals perceive their own worth from the very beginning of their careers.
P.S. I’ve done unpaid internships myself so yes, the frustration in this reply comes from lived experience 😅
minimalist phone: creating folders
@rashiaroraofficial I think when there is repetitive, monotonous work, it is not "learning." Learning takes at most 1 month, then you are exploiting cheap labour. If creative work.... then yes, you are learning, because in creative work you are given a different scope of problems.
IXORD
I also believe that interns should be paid, as it is a good start for their careers and it helps build loyalty to the company. In the past, it was difficult to find a job where interns were paid anything at all
minimalist phone: creating folders
@ixord I can believe that some companies still expect to not pay them anything :D
IXORD
@busmark_w_nika Unfortunately, this is the reality, but I hope the situation will improve
minimalist phone: creating folders
@ixord 🤞
In Brazil, we have both, but they are limited to working a maximum of 6 hours per day. This applies whether the internship is paid or unpaid.
If you are a paid intern, you receive half the minimum salary and cannot be asked to perform like a normal employee. We have strict rules against this, and we are all governed by a norm called CLT, which basically rules all employee-employer contracts, bonds, and relationships.
Personally, I was an unpaid intern in engineering. Mostly, you don't receive tasks or anything like that; you just get a permit to be there. When you are a paid intern, things are different. You receive some tasks and minimal responsibilities.
We also have programs in my city called "Young Apprentice." It's like an intern program, but you don't need to be currently enrolled in a bachelor's degree. So, you can work as an intern even if you have no prior education after high school. It's for even younger people; if you are 16 and below 25, you can do this without being matriculated in a university.
When I was working in a company, we had young apprentices and paid interns. They both worked similarly, but the paid interns were pushed to perform more than the young apprentices. In this particular case, both were paid for their working hours and only allowed to work a maximum of 6 hours per day.
There are other differences between the two roles, but they are very similar. They are all meant for people who need to discover how to work, learn the work, and understand the basics of the business.
minimalist phone: creating folders
@tuliosousapro It seems that Brazil is quite strict, but I like how you worked on this system. It seems like it is working well. Because if anything is set by rule or gov, companies are more likely to respect it.
MultiDrive
From my experience, internships were always paid - both my own and those at the companies where I worked. Interns did real work, just a bit slower while learning, but they were never completely without knowledge.
minimalist phone: creating folders
@tetianai Just out of curiosity, what was your 1st internship? 👀
MultiDrive
@busmark_w_nika It was a sales role. There was a learning curve, but I was very focused on results from day one and managed to deliver good outcomes. We were slower than experienced colleagues at first, but motivation really made the difference. :)
minimalist phone: creating folders
@tetianai That feeling that in an internship you make better than a full-time employee. 💅
my take is that I don't want to stop anyone from taking an unpaid internship if they go in with their eyes fully open. On the other hand, at a macro-economic or policy level, I don't want conditions such that large numbers of people are forced into unpaid work just to get a chance at paid work.
minimalist phone: creating folders
@michael_cardno IMO, paid internships will be so standardised that young people will not take them for free. But also companies will have AI, so it will be for them way cheaper to have "bot" than "overpaid intern who is still learning).