Alex Gap

In-Depth Reviews - Reviews that ask better questions

In-Depth Reviews capture what real makers and users think about the tools they rely on. Each review highlights the best and worst features, answers product-specific questions, and includes what the reviewer built using the product.

Add a comment

Replies

Best
Danny Brown-Wolf

Reviews are usually gamed - esp in depth ones.
There is infra being built in identity / action verification using blockchain that can verify user + usage to add credibility to a review. Have you looked into those? How are you verifying the authenticity?

Rajiv Ayyangar

@danny_brown_wolf We look at a variety of signals right now, and are also rolling out user verification.

The most salient way you can tell authenticity on Product Hunt is by looking at what this person has built (e.g. the product after their name). Though right now, this only applies to people who have launched things on Product Hunt, which is partly why we're rolling out the green checkmarks.

Chris Messina

@makers: please update your Changelog! Then I'll write a nice review. 😉

Gabe Perez
Giulia Borghi

Very useful, congrats on the launch and thanks for this upgrade!

Giulia Borghi

Very useful, congrats on the launch and thanks for this upgrade!

Giulia Borghi

Very useful, congrats on the launch and thanks for this upgrade!

Lucian Liu

Yooo, In-Depth Reviews sounds awesome! 🔥 Ngl, I'm all about getting better perspectives before buying. Quick Q - how do you decide which questions to ask in your reviews? This could really change the game! Keep it up, makers! 🎉

Sarrah
This is freaking awesome! Much needed gesture. One thing that bothers me sometimes about PH is the shallow and sometimes clearly fabricated reviews just meant to boost a post. Had the team thought through how this might handle review integrity? It’s okay if the answer is “it won’t” then that’s fine too. Just curious about the scope.
Fredo Tan

Very nice interactive demo!

I was always thought that was a missing piece on Product Hunt. Looking forward to seeing in-depth reviews used widely across PH.