What are the most common mistakes that first time launchers do on Product Hunt?
After monitoring Product Hunt for several years and receiving countless requests for help, I've realised what the most common mistakes are among first-time launchers.
I'll try to outline a few:
They don't prepare a launch plan. They launch without any real preparation (structure). I often receive messages during launch day asking how to get more upvotes or whether I'd be willing to become a co-maker so they can add me retroactively.
They don't complete their profiles properly. Both their personal profiles and product launch pages are often incomplete. They don't get featured then.
They schedule their launch for the middle of the day. This leaves them with less time to collect upvotes and generate engagement.
They don't communicate enough about their launch. They underestimate pre-launch promotion, activity during launch day, and especially post-launch communication.
They start asking people for support and platform registrations on launch day. These upvotes may be considered irrelevant and could undermine the credibility of the launch. Also, avoid sending all your emails at once. Schedule them in batches instead.
I'm sure there are plenty of other mistakes, though.
What do you consider the most obvious mistakes first-time Product Hunt launchers make?

p/interview-coach-3
p/runevr
p/producthunt
p/google-cloud-platform
p/findergit
p/lancetta
p/reso
p/many-displays
p/slotify-2
p/airuncode
p/kodlo
p/ai-context-flow
p/dino-kids
p/supabase
p/jev
p/lasso-11
p/aperture-7
p/raycast
p/murror
p/kuc-kuc
Replies
Another big mistake is focusing only on launch-day upvotes instead of building a genuine community and getting early user feedback before launch
@shivam_kushwaha16 one more thing that came to my mind. People focus only on Product Day. They can make the most of it... by focusing on the product of the week or month too :)
@busmark_w_nika I have noticed the same thing. Most people focus only on Product of the Day and often ignore Product of the Week Month or even Year
This question came to my mind too so I spoke with a few founders and asked why they launch on Product Hunt
Their answers were quite different One founder told me they launch mainly to get the Product of the Day badge because it can help increase their conversion rate Another said they don’t really care about badges or rankings They just want a few genuine users who will use their product and share feedback
That’s when I realized that every founder has a different perspective and their own goals. Some want visibility and conversions while others simply want real users and honest feedback It all depends on what they actually need from their launch
@shivam_kushwaha16 Do you have any data on the fact whether products with the badge really had the better conversion rate?
@busmark_w_nika I don’t have any official data to prove it but one founder whose launch ranked #1 told me that their conversion rate was around 1% before getting the Product of the Day badge After receiving the badge, it increased to around 3%
Personally I believe the badge does make a difference because it works as social proof It gives people a sense that the product is valuable and worth trying. We all have a natural tendency to trust and try things that are recognized as the best or ranked at the top.
So while a badge doesn’t guarantee better conversions I believe it can definitely help build trust and improve conversion rates
@shivam_kushwaha16 What is your strategy of getting early users and for their feedback? If you don't mind sharing.
@richatsealedvault For getting early users, I usually start with my own network. My first users often come from LinkedIn because I have 22K+ followers there.
Whenever I launch a SaaS product, I first promote it through my own LinkedIn account without spending anything on ads. Once I reach around 100 users, I invite them to my Discord community where I discuss the problems they face, bugs they find and things they would like to improve. Then I work on fixing those issues based on their feedback.
Once around 50% of my users are satisfied with the product, I start investing some budget in promotion.
One of the biggest mistakes founders make is waiting until their product is 100% perfect before launching or promoting it. Honestly, that’s a bad approach. No SaaS product or application is ever 100% perfect. Even ChatGPT and Claude have bugs and limitations, but millions of people still use them.
You don’t need a perfect product to get started. You need real users who can help you make it better.
And if you don’t have a network like mine, you can skip my first step and start with Reddit. It can be a great place to reach potential users and get early feedback, but understanding how Reddit works takes some research. So I’d suggest spending some time learning how to use it properly
@shivam_kushwaha16 Thank you so much, this is very informative and helpful. I hope other readers here find so much value in what you just shared. Getting early users to try a new SaaS product is one of the biggest hurdles for new founders so I know what you have shared will help many.
The other question I wanted to ask you was do these early users try the SaaS for free and for how long? My observation on PH tells me most founders struggle to find paid users. May be not very difficult to find free users but paid users is another level.
@richatsealedvault @shivam_kushwaha16 This is a gold advice!
They don't build hype before.
especially hype in the right spaces.
not everyone has a product hunt account, you need one to vote.
So you need to build that specific momentum
@build_with_aj Well, one account should have a history to be more trustworthy. 2 weeks minimum.
asking for upvotes before anyone has actually tried it. a few honest comments from people who used the thing are worth more than a hundred blind upvotes
@farzam_habibi When it comes to trying the product out... I would first choose people who would really find it helpful. I will not be asking people who don't use LinkedIn to try out my LinkedIn tool. Because they are not the target audience. :D
@farzam_habibi Agree. That is why I ask people to run the scan and tell me what it got wrong.
This is an insightful discussion. I'm very interested. Preparation is key to success on anything and project. So the question is how should first-time launcher prepare to avoid costly mistakes?
@richatsealedvault I think that the best way to learn is to follow recent successful launches and copy as much as possible.
Point 5 about batching the asks is a good one. One I would add is a thin launch gallery: visitors judge from the first image and the first maker comment before they read anything else, so a single flat screenshot loses them fast. A few real use scenes, a short clip, and a first comment that tells the story of why you built it do a lot more work than a longer description.
@tomer_bar_meir Do you think that videos are better than images? Because I started to have that impression.
@busmark_w_nika Good question. In a feed a short clip usually holds attention longer, while a clean image is faster to scan and works better on listings and product pages. So I would not pick one: lead with the clip where people scroll, keep a strong still as the cover and for the gallery.
the post-launch communication point stands out, since a lot of people seem to treat day two as the finish line. what would a good follow-up in the week after look like, a thank-you thread or something with actual numbers?
@neerajnathany Do you mean in DMs or a post?
@busmark_w_nika a post, like a short thread in p/general with a couple of real numbers and what you changed afterwards. which format have you seen get the most replies?
One I made myself: launching several products within a few days of each other. Every launch needs the same person answering comments all day, and when you stack them you end up half-present at each one.
Another: treating the launch page as the only place people will read. The posts that got real replies for us were forum threads in the weeks before, each about one small decision we had made and ending with a question we actually wanted answered, not an announcement.
Nika, from what you've seen, does a product that wasn't featured on day one ever recover through the week after, or is that mostly decided in the first hours?
@ksanyokm To be honest, I haven't experienced on my own that a product went from the non-featured to the featured section. But that usually happens (that transition within a day, as I noticed). Maybe because makers or hunters reach out to support or get significant support that cannot be ignored, and maybe the combination.
@busmark_w_nika Thanks, that matches what I've seen too: if it changes, it's within the same day, not a slow climb over the week. So the real lever is everything before 00:01, not the days after.
First launch today, so good timing. The joke is on me: I built a tool that helps with launches and still got my own launch prep wrong.
The tool did its part. It found the threads and drafted the replies. But I am also the one building it, and I was still shipping code the morning of the launch. I should have blocked a week or two for nothing except reaching out and being around here.
So it is live, not featured, and the only visitors so far are people I messaged myself.
Is there anything left to do on launch day once you are not featured? Or is that settled before? Any experienced Product Hunters out there that can share some wisdom?
Before launch, the coding agent reported clean tests on onboarding, but it had silently stubbed out the failure paths. When launch traffic hit blank screens, early trust was burned not because the code failed, but because users were assured everything was fine based on that output.