Do always-on donation buttons still work?
I'm launching QuietJar here next Tuesday, and before that I'd like to hear how you handle this.
Most support buttons sit on every page, every day. On my own site, TCG Pocket Collection Tracker, the Buy Me a Coffee button brought in about €30 a month. Visitors had learned to look past it.
In September I swapped it for a goal: €50 to cover that month's hosting. It raised €97 in 12 hours, and then the button disappeared until October.
That made me think the button itself isn't the problem. The ask is. When there's a concrete cost and a finish line, people act. When the button asks forever, nobody feels their euro matters.
A few questions for anyone running a site, docs, blog or open source project:
Do you have a support or donate button, and does it still bring anything in?
Would you rather show a specific goal, like hosting or the next release, than a general "support me"?
Would hiding the button once the goal is met feel right, or like leaving money on the table?
Curious to hear what has and hasn't worked for you.

p/runevr
p/producthunt
p/google-cloud-platform
p/raycast
p/kuc-kuc
p/offiai
p/lasso-11
p/kodlo
p/ai-context-flow
p/many-displays
p/reso
p/dex-by-exmergo
p/dino-kids
p/htmldrag
p/supabase
p/jev
p/murror
p/nexupira
p/jot-2-0
p/beamfy
Replies
Be the first to reply
Have a question or a thought to share? Add a comment above to start the conversation.