shouldIApply
Should you even apply for that job? An honest yes or no
Start new thread

shouldIApply - Should you even apply for that job? An honest yes or no

byā€¢
shouldIApply matches your resume against a job posting and gives an honest GO or NO-GO ā€” even when the answer is "don't bother." See the ATS keywords you're missing and get a truthful rewrite only when you're actually a match. Free resume checker + keyword library included.

Add a comment

Replies

Best
Maker
šŸ“Œ
Hey Product Hunt šŸ‘‹ I built shouldIApply after watching too many people (myself included) pour hours into job applications that were never going to land ā€” tailoring resumes, writing cover letters, hitting "submit," and hearing nothing back. Here's the thing that bugged me: most resume tools make money when you keep scanning, so they always nudge you to "improve your score and apply!" ā€” even for jobs you have no real shot at. I wanted the opposite. A tool honest enough to tell you "don't bother, this one isn't worth your time." So that's what shouldIApply does. Paste your resume and a job posting, and you get: ā€¢ An honest GO or NO-GO verdict in about 20 seconds ā€¢ The exact ATS keywords you're missing ā€¢ A truthful rewrite ā€” only when you're actually a match (it won't fabricate experience you don't have) There's also a free resume checker and an ATS keyword library, no signup needed. The honest "no" is the whole point ā€” it's the thing competitors structurally can't copy, because their business depends on you scanning more. I'd genuinely love your feedback, especially on this: when you're job hunting, would you actually want a tool to tell you NOT to apply ā€” or does that feel discouraging? I've gone back and forth on it and I'm curious what this community thinks. Thanks for checking it out šŸ™ ā€” Akshay

Love how it tells you not to bother instead of hyping every role. That honest filter saves so much time and feels way more trustworthy than the usual "you're a perfect match" fluff.

Maker

Ā "Trustworthy" is the word I care about most, so this genuinely means a lot. The industry norm of telling everyone they're a perfect match is exactly what I wanted to push against ā€” it's not helping anyone. Thanks for getting it, and for taking the time to say so šŸ™

Tried it on a senior role I was eyeing and got a NO-GO plus the exact keywords I was missing, which honestly saved me from wasting an hour tailoring my resume. Love that it doesn't try to sugarcoat things.

Maker

Ā This is exactly what I built it for ā€” that "saved me from wasting an hour" moment is the whole point. Tailoring a resume for a job you were never landing is the most demoralizing kind of busywork. Thanks so much for trying it on a real role, and for the kind words šŸ™

Love the honest "don't bother" angle, that alone makes this stand out from the usual resume scanner fluff. One thing I'd love: a side-by-side comparison of two different jobs so I can see which one I'm actually a stronger fit for before I start tailoring anything.

Maker

Ā Really appreciate this šŸ™ And that side-by-side idea is a great one ā€” being able to compare two jobs and see which you're a stronger fit for before investing any tailoring time fits the whole "don't waste effort" philosophy perfectly. Adding it to the list ā€” this is the kind of feedback that actually shapes what I build next. Thank you.

Maker

Ā Thanks again for the great suggestion. I wanted to let you know I've implemented side-by-side job comparison so you can compare multiple opportunities and make a more informed decision before applying.

If you have a chance, I'd really appreciate it if you could give it another try and let me know how it works on your end. Your feedback has already helped improve the product. Let me know and I can share the access code, please submit access code request via the website form.

You can try it here:

Looking forward to hearing your thoughts! šŸš€