Paid an agency $20k to redesign our landing page. Our conversion rate dropped by 60%.
For the first year of our SaaS, our landing page was functional but ugly. It was built by me using a basic template, but it converted at a solid 4%—which was enough to keep us growing steadily.
We decided it was time to look "premium," so we hired a high-end branding and design agency. We paid them $20,000 and waited six weeks for them to deliver a stunning, modern, animated landing page. It looked like a Silicon Valley unicorn's website. We launched it on a Tuesday.
By Friday, our conversion rate had completely collapsed.
We went from a 4% conversion rate to 1.6% overnight. The agency had removed all the "ugly but effective" elements: they deleted the customer testimonials because they "cluttered the design," they replaced our clear, benefit-driven headline with a vague, abstract tagline ("Unleash Your Potential"), and they made the call-to-action button a subtle shade of gray that blended into the background.
I called the agency to complain, and they basically told me it was our fault for not having "better traffic." But I know my traffic didn't change—they just designed a beautiful piece of art that forgot to sell the product.
I just paid $20,000 to destroy our main source of revenue. We are now scrambling to A/B test the old elements back in, which essentially means paying them $20k to undo their own work.
For founders who have paid for professional design: How do you ensure an agency prioritizes conversion and usability over just making things look pretty?
Do you force them to follow a specific conversion framework? Do you run usability tests on the new design before a full launch? I need to figure out how to get a premium look without killing our sales.
Replies
Next time I'd launch any redesign as a 50/50 split against the old page rather than a straight swap, so a drop shows up within days and only costs you half the traffic. It also helps to hand the agency a short list of things that can't be removed, like the testimonials and the headline, before anyone opens Figma. Pretty and converting aren't at odds, the agency just needs to know which bits are doing the selling.