How would a meaningful comment about a launch be made?
I put more effort into reading launch comments than the launches themselves, and there seems to be a common trend. About half of all comments contain congratulatory messages and wishes for success, a quarter of all comments ask something the maker had already mentioned on the page, and the other half are valuable comments.
Valuable comments always have a format. They mention the specific feature the user has tried, they describe expectations vs. results and ask one specific question. Last week I read a comment on a scheduling application where the commenter noticed that the time zone selector started with the time zone of the city where the maker lives. It was fixed by the maker within an hour, and the answer included a screenshot.
This is something that I try to do in my comments too, but it isn't always easy. It requires me to get into the product and spend at least ten minutes clicking around and forming an opinion. This is quite a task given that there are twenty new releases everyday.
So how about it? Do you set a time limit for your comment or make notes while testing? And from the point of view of a creator, what is the one comment that has had maximum influence on you even though it may have hurt you a bit?
Replies
Be the first to reply
Have a question or a thought to share? Add a comment above to start the conversation.