Does cold emailing still work, or are we just shouting into a digital void?
by•
In our first three months, my co-founder and I sent over 2,000 personalized cold emails. We spent hours researching each prospect, crafting custom hooks, and following up meticulously. Our reply rate? A dismal 2% with zero closed deals.
The moment we stopped cold pitching and started sharing our raw building process publicly on LinkedIn and Twitter, leads started inbound organically. People didn't want a generic pitch; they wanted to buy from humans they trusted. Is traditional cold outreach officially dead for early-stage founders, or were we just doing it completely wrong?
How do you build pipeline without feeling like a spammer?
11 views
p/runevr
p/producthunt
p/google-cloud-platform
p/aperture-7
p/raycast
p/kuc-kuc
p/lasso-11
p/kodlo
p/ai-context-flow
p/offiai
p/many-displays
p/reso
p/dino-kids
p/dex-by-exmergo
p/supabase
p/jev
p/htmldrag
p/murror
p/nexupira
p/jot-2-0
Replies
People are now wary of cold emails. They’ve spent so much time online—both after the pandemic and with the rise of AI—that they’re longing for an offline experience. I heard on a marketing podcast that brands are now organizing events instead of sending cold emails.
Even when I send welcome emails to my members, they don’t respond. But I still think there’s hope. I think we’re writing things that feel very artificial. We’re approaching it as if it were just a task, rather than showing genuine interest.
If we change our approach, cold emails could still have potential. But we need to take the time to write sincerely. I don’t know yet how to automate this. The only thing I know is to write sincerely to fewer people.