Does cold emailing still work, or are we just shouting into a digital void?

by•

In our first three months, my co-founder and I sent over 2,000 personalized cold emails. We spent hours researching each prospect, crafting custom hooks, and following up meticulously. Our reply rate? A dismal 2% with zero closed deals.

The moment we stopped cold pitching and started sharing our raw building process publicly on LinkedIn and Twitter, leads started inbound organically. People didn't want a generic pitch; they wanted to buy from humans they trusted. Is traditional cold outreach officially dead for early-stage founders, or were we just doing it completely wrong?
How do you build pipeline without feeling like a spammer?

11 views

Add a comment

Replies

Best

People are now wary of cold emails. They’ve spent so much time online—both after the pandemic and with the rise of AI—that they’re longing for an offline experience. I heard on a marketing podcast that brands are now organizing events instead of sending cold emails.

Even when I send welcome emails to my members, they don’t respond. But I still think there’s hope. I think we’re writing things that feel very artificial. We’re approaching it as if it were just a task, rather than showing genuine interest.

If we change our approach, cold emails could still have potential. But we need to take the time to write sincerely. I don’t know yet how to automate this. The only thing I know is to write sincerely to fewer people.