A $500/mo customer canceled. Our cancellation flow was so bad they left a 1-star review.
Last week, a customer on our $500/month plan decided to cancel. It happens—churn is part of SaaS. But what happened next was a masterclass in bad user experience that I didn't even know existed in our own product.
I pulled up their account timeline to see what went wrong. Here's what I found:
To cancel, they had to click through four different screens and answer a mandatory survey.
The "Cancel" button was a tiny gray link, while the "Keep My Plan" button was a giant green button.
After they finally canceled, they received an automated email that said: "We're sorry to see you go. Your data will be permanently deleted in 24 hours."
There was no option to export their data, no offer for a pause or discount, and no way to reactivate their account if they changed their mind.
The customer was furious. They left a detailed 1-star review on G2 and Trustpilot, calling us "a company that traps users and holds their data hostage."
I was mortified. I never designed this flow intentionally—it was just the default settings from our billing provider. I never tested it myself because I was too focused on acquiring new customers, not on the experience of the ones leaving.
Now I'm realizing that a bad offboarding experience doesn't just lose you a customer—it turns them into an active detractor who will warn others away from your product.
For founders who have audited their cancellation flow: How did you redesign your offboarding to actually leave a good last impression?
Do you offer a one-click pause instead of a cancellation? Do you provide a seamless data export? I need to figure out how to turn a churn into a "see you later" instead of a "never again."
Replies
Be the first to reply
Have a question or a thought to share? Add a comment above to start the conversation.