My honest alpha review of my own app: what works and what doesn't

by•

I've been building BudgetClick for 4 months and testing it myself as an alpha user. Since I'm obviously biased, here's an honest review, including the parts that aren't great yet.

What I like:

  • The app does what I wanted: tracking, budgeting and planning on all my devices, with my data staying mine.

  • The UX is simple enough, and I especially like the one-screen layout. Transactions and the big-picture widgets are always in front of me.

  • An unexpected side effect: since each budget lives in its own storage bucket, you can keep several separate budgets, one per bucket.

What's still hard:

  • Setting up the S3 bucket is the hardest part. It's the price of money-free privacy: no accounts, no BudgetClick servers, storage you own. But it is a real hurdle.

  • Choosing a passphrase that is strong and memorable at the same time is hard. It's never stored and there is no recovery, so this matters.

  • Offline work is still a bit shaky. I'm working on it.

I'd like to hear from you:

  1. If you tried it, how did the setup go? Where did you get stuck?

  2. Is the S3 setup an acceptable trade-off for privacy, or a dealbreaker? What would make it easier?

  3. How do you handle strong passphrases you can still remember?

  4. Does the idea of several separate budgets sound useful? How would you use it?

Try it here:

Any feedback is welcome, including the harsh kind.

37 views

Add a comment

Replies

Best

Tip: if the S3 setup looks intimidating, try the interactive storage setup walkthrough first: . Tell me which step is the least clear and I'll fix it.