Paid a growth agency $5k/mo for 6 months. They generated 12 leads and zero closed deals.
Six months ago, we hit a plateau at $15k MRR and decided we needed external help to scale. We hired a highly recommended B2B growth agency. They promised to build us a "predictable outbound sales engine" using LinkedIn and cold email. We signed a retainer for $5,000/month.
For the first few months, the reports they sent looked incredible. They were sending 2,000 emails a week, running LinkedIn campaigns, and building custom landing pages. I felt relieved. I thought we had finally outsourced our growth problem.
But last week, I decided to do a deep dive into the actual CRM data, not just their reports. The reality was devastating:
In 6 months, they generated exactly 12 qualified leads.
Of those 12 leads, 0 have closed.
We paid them $30,000** in total retainers, which is roughly **$2,500 per lead.
When I looked at the email sequences they sent, they were incredibly generic, badly written, and didn't mention a single specific pain point our product solves.
When I confronted them, they blamed our product, saying "the market just isn't ready for this solution." But I know my product works—we had $15k MRR from founder-led sales before hiring them. They just didn't know how to sell it.
I realized I made the classic founder mistake: I outsourced the hardest part of the business (finding out what messaging actually converts) to people who didn't understand the product. I just wasted $30,000 and six months of runway on a vanity retainer.
For founders who have used agencies: How do you structure a deal so you don't end up paying for zero results?
Do you require performance-based pricing (a percentage of closed revenue)? Do you demand access to the raw CRM data and sequences they are using? I need to figure out how to hold people accountable before I ever sign another retainer.
Replies
Be the first to reply
Have a question or a thought to share? Add a comment above to start the conversation.