Don't you think that many people on PH ask unnecessary questions rather than intellectual ones?
Nitin Joshi
32 replies
There's a flood of discussion on PH, but I've found most of it to be repetitive, unnecessary, and unrelated to the industry. I came here to participate or learn something new, but I'm disappointed with those questions! What do you think of it?
Replies
Juan Manuel Dato@juan_manuel_dato
Good discussions could be about:
Deontology: the branch of ethics that deals with the rightness or wrongness of actions based on their conformity to duty or obligation.
Technical marketing advice: advice on how to market products or services using technical expertise.
Production management: the process of planning, organizing, directing, and controlling the production of goods or services.
Mathematical and physical technological limits: the limits of what is possible with technology, based on mathematical or physical principles.
How foreign policy affects: the impact of foreign policy on a variety of issues, such as trade, security, and culture.
Development dilemmas: complex challenges that arise in the process of development.
Ideas for how to develop products: new or innovative ways to develop products.
Analysis of why some projects fail: the reasons why some projects do not achieve their objectives.
Catalog of catalogs: a collection of catalogs.
However, when we are forced to discuss discussions or to promote products, it is possible that either quality is lost or an emergency bypass is being made - in the sense that an excess of bypass kills anyone.
This means that it is important to have discussions that are focused on the topic at hand and that are productive. Discussions that are simply about having discussions or that are used to promote products are often not as valuable.
Share
Yes, Nitin, I have also encountered numerous repetitive and unnecessary questions. I choose to ignore them.
@alyssaphillips Exactly! We must focus on learning rather than earning PH points or just for streaks. I would not skip a single day If something motivate me to access PH daily. what you think..?
yes. You are right
I pretty much agree. I would love to see more threads about industry-related topics, but at the same time, I see they don't perform very well. Nonetheless if I find something interesting I'll reply :)
I see a lot of repetitiveness on PH but I see tons of unnecessary questions on Twitter. People ask pointless philosophical questions to try and seem smart or contrarian. It makes it hard to stay active IMO.
This is true. But such discussions with "unnecessary" questions are generally much more popular.
Absolutely, not only that but it's easy to point out all the comments that are generated by AI. More than a bit disappointing if you're looking for real discussions.
And so many are AI generated. Sigh!
I think it's because people come here with a purpose, usually centered around their product. I do want to see some deep dives though.
That's clearly true, Nitin. I always try to either say something important (or relevant at least), or nothing at all.
But with this stragy it's difficult to get many followers since I don't often have time to think what important things could be said on PH.
Big problems with this "forum" that lead to repetitiveness:
No subforums, no good search, only discussions started during the last day are shown by default.
@konrad_sx My motive aligns with yours! When I post something, it's usually because I have a question in mind that's relevant to the platform. However, fewer people tend to participate. 😁
Not only are there unnecessary questions, but there are also many fake accounts using the profile pictures of Instagram influencers. It's like making PH the third Facebook, with LinkedIn being the second. LOL.
I Agree with you!
this is true, not even PH on LinkedIn people post Irrelevant post which is very disappointing!