Reviewers see Tally as a simple, Notion-like form builder that stays easy to use even when forms get complex. They repeatedly praise fast setup, clean design, conditional logic, hidden fields, calculations, embeds, and broad integrations with tools like Airtable, Notion, Google Sheets, and Coda. Many say it replaced Typeform, Jotform, or Google Forms in real workflows such as client intake, registrations, research, and internal requests. Criticism is limited but specific: some want stronger analytics, templates, mobile polish, undo, and clearer limits around heavy free-tier usage.