The text fields in the 'Share Your Idea' submission form are excellent. People who share ideas have to think through a commercial lens. The copy they upload at the instigation of an idea doesn't have to be fully formed – as this is the beauty of receiving feedback from the IdeasNest community – but the seeds of whether or not an idea has legs are planted right at the inception of publishing the idea.
The beauty of IdeasNest is that it is built on the concept of idea validation. The team behind the tool is small and agile. This means that any good ideas for improving the site can be implemented quickly and seamlessly to maintain the high quality of the service.
IdeasNest has an in-built community of founders and mentors well used to sharing useful advice and valuable insights with the people who upload ideas. The tool is free to use. Ideas can be located in either public and private nests for inviting feedback.
IdeasNest offers something that many entrepreneurs genuinely need: a place where you can share an idea and receive thoughtful, constructive feedback from people who are willing to challenge your assumptions.
I recently shared Fleximent™, an industrialized construction technology platform that we are developing internationally.
What followed was far more valuable than I initially expected.
Through several rounds of discussion, Simon Krystman asked some genuinely challenging questions about our commercialization approach, market validation and early customer adoption.
Rather than simply receiving encouragement, I found myself reconsidering important assumptions and making substantial improvements to our strategy.
As an entrepreneur with more than 25 years of experience in property development and construction, I particularly value feedback that makes me think differently.
That is what IdeasNest delivered.
I initially experienced some frustrating technical issues when trying to edit and save my idea using Google Chrome.
However, what impressed me was Simon's response. He investigated the problems, identified the causes, implemented fixes and restored my original submission.
The platform is still developing, and I haven't yet retested every function, but the willingness to listen and respond constructively is encouraging.
Many startup communities offer networking, encouragement or opportunities to promote an idea.
IdeasNest has the potential to offer something more valuable: meaningful dialogue that actually influences how an entrepreneur develops an idea.
For me, the most important outcome wasn't visibility or encouragement. It was that constructive external feedback led to real strategic improvements.
That alone makes IdeasNest worth exploring.
I genuinely hope more founders, experienced entrepreneurs, investors and mentors join the community, because the real value of a platform like this grows with the quality of the people participating.
Highly recommended!
Thank you Rolf, and thank you especially for including the part that did not work.
The editing bug was real and there were two separate faults. The submit button disabled itself whenever it thought an image was the wrong format, and the validation messages were hidden inside collapsed sections, so the form refused to submit with nothing on screen explaining why. Both are fixed and your original submission is restored. Worth a retest when you have a moment, since you are the person who found it.
One thing I should be straight about for anyone reading this. The questions you got came from me, not from a crowd. That is the honest position at this stage of the platform. The aim is for that kind of challenge to come from a lot of experienced people rather than one, and reviews like yours are how that starts.
For what it is worth, the changes you made to the pilot partner sequencing were yours. I only asked the awkward question.
What I like most about IdeasNest is how low the barrier is. You don't need a pitch deck or a polished plan, you just answer four simple questions: who it's for, why there's demand, who your ideal customers are and how you'd reach them. That structure forces you to think clearly, and it gives people reading your idea something concrete to react to, so the feedback is useful and not just "cool idea, good luck".
It's also free with no paywall, and nothing pushes you to give away your IP, which removes the usual fear of sharing early. The private nests are a smart touch too. I work with cohorts and training groups, and having a closed space where a group can share ideas only among themselves is exactly what those settings need.
Full disclosure: I know the maker, and I've seen how much care went into this. Happy to see it live.
It's launch day, so the community is still small. As more founders and mentors join, the feedback will get richer.
Usually early ideas end up in a Notion doc, a WhatsApp group or a Reddit thread, where feedback is either scattered or too generic. IdeasNest gives the idea a proper format and an audience of founders and mentors who are there for that purpose.
Thank you Gianluca and thank you for the disclosure, which you didn't have to make.
The nests point is the one I'll take away. You work with cohorts and training groups, and that's exactly who they were built for, but it's the part of IdeasNest almost nobody discovers unless they're told. If you ever want one set up for a group of yours, say the word.
And you're right about the community being small today, that's the honest state of it. There are 186 ideas up there, most imported from the old site, and the whole job this year is getting the people behind them talking to each other again. Today was a start.
12Ronnies should be THE description in every start-up dictionary for "cool". Why? Because it leaves nothing behind that needs to be considered when you've started a company. The format, the peer reviews, the experienced operator opinions and suggestions. All of these provide the best foundation a start-up could hope for to be successful. Really! It's not so much that you don't need to go anywhere else other than 12Ronnies. But know that if you don't, you haven't skipped anything important. Check it out and see for yourself.
It would be great if the comments section allowed editing, instead of just straight deletion.
The closest "competitor" is any and every start-up forum. The difference is every single one of those essentially let's you run freely amuck with no direction or purpose, or is akin to an opinion sight where posts are meant not to benefit you, but to advertise what they are doing.
Mario, the editing point is a fair hit, and a slightly embarrassing one: the database has had an edited_at column for comments since the rebuild, so the intent was always there. I just never built the screen. Delete-and-repost is a poor substitute, particularly when someone's spotted a typo in a long reply. I'll get it done.
On the rest, thank you, genuinely. Your idea is also the one I point at when people ask what a fully worked entry looks like: all nine sections answered, real figures, a proper argument about demand. It sets the standard for the gallery.
And your line about other forums letting you "run amuck with no direction" is precisely why the four questions are compulsory. Several people have told me today that's too much friction. You've just made the case for it better than I did.
It's free, with no paywall and no pitch deck needed, so there's no barrier to sharing an idea early.
You don't have to reveal your IP, which removes one of the biggest reasons people keep ideas to themselves.
Samer — thank you, and you're the third person to independently pick out the IP point. That surprises me, because it's the thing I've given the least prominence to on the site. You've all got there on your own, which probably means it should be the first thing people read rather than something they discover.
One thing though: you gave reliability four out of five, and it's the only mark that isn't full. I'd genuinely like to know what you hit. A slow page, something that didn't load, a link that went nowhere? Three real bugs got found and fixed this week because people bothered to say, so I'd rather hear it than guess.
And you're not signed up, which means you've reviewed it purely from the outside. If you ever want to put an idea up, it'll get a proper read.
