The best alternatives to Icon Shop are Nova, Ego Icons, and Milk Icons. If these 3 options don't work for you, we've listed a few more alternatives below.
What do you think of Icon Shop?
Haggle — A CTA buyers want to click, when they aren't ready to demo
Mapbox is an American provider of custom online maps, navigation, address search, and location data for websites and applications such as Foursquare, Lonely Planet, Facebook, the Financial Times, The Weather Ch...