Seedproof

Get feedback for your startup ideas πŸ”₯

#3 Product of the DayJanuary 13, 2018

Seedproof is where startup ideas stand or fall on their own merits.

Your startup should be all about making an awesome product, not about becoming a marketing guru just to find out if you have a good idea. We'll take care of getting you feedback so you can focus on building something people want. πŸš€

Reviews
  • Gautam Lakum
    Gautam LakumDesign Sprint Master β€’ Product Designer
    Pros:Β 

    Good initiative

    Cons:Β 

    A lot of improvements required on the web platform. UI/UX is not user friendly at all. It's tedious to perform some actions on it.

    A few examples: it shows a php error on registration, it asks to upload a profile photo everytime you edit it even if it is already there. Looks like the platform is not tested well.

    Gautam Lakum has used this product for one month.
    Comments (0)
  • Alex Circei
    Alex CirceiCEO & Co-founder Waydev
    Pros:Β 

    nice initiative

    Cons:Β 

    more data

    I would like to connect an investor though your platform.

    Alex Circei has used this product for one day.
    Comments (0)
Discussion
MakerPro
Hey, thanks for checking out Seedproof πŸ‘‹ This is our beta so please let us know what we can do to make it more valuable to you and your startup. Our goal is for ideas to stand or fall on their own merit - no marketing or PPC required. We will make sure other founders see your ideas and give you feedback. Many of my ideas were things nobody wanted, but I spent a lot of time on them because I thought the product would be cool. But if you're like me at all you really don't want to create something nobody wants. Seedproof is a platform to help all of us make things people want. Here's how it works: 1. Share your startup idea πŸ’‘ 2. We ensure others vote it up/down and leave feedback βœ”οΈ ❌ πŸ’¬ 3. You can see all of your stats and get the direction/support you need to move forward πŸš€ If you'd like to check it out: https://seedproof.com πŸ™ Thanks again! Andrew
I like the idea but I think the design of the web could improve, it's all tight
MakerPro
@edwardvasquezdr thank you! We have a lot of improvement to do!!
I like the new trend of apps dedicated to idea validation! Lean startups will have a new tool in their box!
MakerPro
@osmanbassam thanks for the kind words!! I agree...it's much more efficient
What were the steps that you took to validate your idea for Seedproof? Thanks!
MakerPro
@adamwebber haha I was surprised nobody asked that yet!! But I couldn't really...I had to create a functional site and launch a beta product to validate. Thankfully, Seedproof got a lot of interest today. But it's easy (for me) to waste a lot of time building something only to find that I'm the only one who wants it. I'd love to get your thoughts?!
@awt thanks for the reply. I am kicking around an idea so I’ll try posting it up to Seedproof. Do you have analytics that help validate an idea? I love the Seedproof idea, my suggestion would be to team up with someone who has good frontend UI skills and make the site feel super legit like Quora, Dribble and other communities where people post their questions and work to. Once I try it out I’ll send more feedback on the experience. Thanks.
MakerPro
@adamwebber okay thanks. I'll be glad to hear what you think. Probably should have spent more time on the UI and waited to release this. Honestly I didn't know the response on day 1 would be this big!! So definitely have some catch up to do on the UX
@adamwebber @awt great job so far!
MakerPro
@jakemor thanks!!
Nice concept, I think some fonts are a bit too big in my opinion though
MakerPro
@andyz really appreciate the feedback. this is a really good point...it makes it hard to read on some devices!! thank you
@awt Np, will there be a possiblity to comment on ideas? Cause I think that would make the page even much more worthy (Hope I didn't just oversee it).
MakerPro
@andyz thanks! Yes, if you vote up/down there is an opportunity to leave feedback! We need to do some more testing/work on the UX to make it more intuitive and yet still valuable... Glad for your thoughts!