GitLab

Open source alternative to GitHub

#4 Product of the DayJanuary 31, 2015

Reviews

Discussion

MakersThere are no makers yet
You need to become a Contributor to join the discussion - Find out how.
Philip I. Thomas@philipithomas · Co-founder at moonlight
I love gitlab. It's cheaper to run a gitlab server on Digital Ocean than it is to buy a github private account. I use it to back up old projects that I do not want to open source.
James Brooks@jbrooksuk · Founder, Alt Three
We ran GitLab internally for well over a year, however after experiencing a few problems (big repositories, https://github.com/gitlabhq/gitl...), I made the decision that we'd start paying for Private Organisation repositories on GitHub. GitLab is great, but having to manually update everything each month etc started taking its toll on my available time. Whilst GitLab truly is a great piece of software there are a lot of pull requests that are left open on it for a long time, because there doesn't seem to be a roadmap of features until the owners say "Actually, this isn't what we want to do with it." - which is fine, but be more proactive with it.
Sytse Sijbrandij@sytses · CEO, GitLab
@jbrooksuk GitLab B.V. CEO here. Thanks for the feedback James. I'm sorry that you got many 'this request can't be merged with GitLab' errors. It is hard to say what caused this without examining your installation in detail. I saw https://github.com/gitlabhq/gitl... and thought it was solved to your satisfaction, I'm sorry to hear it was not. We understand that the monthly upgrades are a hassle and we plan to make the process easier soon by offering a PPA so you can do apt-get update. Also, you can host your repo's for free at GitLab.com https://about.gitlab.com/gitlab-... You mentioned we don't have a roadmap, this is true since the community is in control. However, we do want to avoid "Actually, this isn't what we want to do with it." situations at all costs. That is why there are over 180 items labeled 'accepting merge requests' on http://feedback.gitlab.com/forum... Please let me know if you have any questions/comments or if I can help in any way.
James Brooks@jbrooksuk · Founder, Alt Three
@sytses Hey, the issue was resolved, but we still decided to move due to not being a Ruby shop and having to manually update every month :) Like I said above, GitLab is great.
Sytse Sijbrandij@sytses · CEO, GitLab
@jbrooksuk Thanks James. Please let me know if we can help moving to GitLab.com in the future. Our last release includes a one-click importer for repositories, issues and comments on issues.