discussion
Would you recommend this product?
No reviews yet
Max Galka
Maker
Builder of dataviz things
Awesome surprise to see my map make it on Product Hunt!
Upvote (15)
Share
Charles KuneneCo-founder @Mountain
@galka_max Great work. Was a bit surprised, especially based on how we discuss immigration in the news today.
Upvote (1)
Share
@galka_max this is cool. It would be interesting to see the same animation, but of people leaving the US over the same time period. I assume more people come than go?
Upvote (4)
Share
Max Galka
Maker
Builder of dataviz things
@davekang Yes, I agree. I've spent a lot of time looking for that data, but the U.S. does not track it. The best estimates I've found go back only a few decades. Still some interesting trends though. Here is the best work I've found on the topic, great series of posts: https://medium.com/migration-iss...
Upvote (1)
Share
Max Galka
Maker
Builder of dataviz things
@charles_kunene Thanks. What about it surprised you? The message it conveys? The lack thereof?
Upvote
Share
Charles KuneneCo-founder @Mountain
@galka_max The current political debate on immigration is centered around people from countries that are predominantly Muslim or Hispanic speaking nations - without acknowledging that those countries only account for a small amount, historically, of immigration to the U.S. This part of the current political climate really frustrates me. I'd be interested to hear if your figures are based on only 'legal' immigration or factor in both legal and illegal immigrants?
Upvote (2)
Share
Ryan Hoover
Hunter
Founder, Product Hunt
Neat visualization. Each dot represents 10,000 people.
Upvote (5)
Share
Yea, that was absolutely mesmerizing and very educational. If you look over it carefully, you will notice a lot of knowledge bombs, like after the 1936, immigration to US seems to calm down dramatically for a couple of years, i wonder why...... ;)
Upvote (3)
Share
Max Galka
Maker
Builder of dataviz things
@dilyaraskar Thanks! There is a good reason for that. After WWI there was a big influx of immigration, so in the 20's the government began limiting it with immigration quotas. The quotas were repealed in the 1960's, which is when the immigration picks back up.
Upvote
Share
Going to school and studying these days is much more exciting... πŸ€“ good ol' days!
Upvote (2)
Share
Max Galka
Maker
Builder of dataviz things
@gabrielpetrolio That's exactly what I find so cool about data visualization. You've probably already seen it, but if not, you should check out some of the videos by Hans Rosling -- it will be the most entertaining and educational 20 minutes you'll spend all week :) https://www.ted.com/talks/hans_r...
Upvote
Share
Alice ThwaiteFounder, Hattusia & Echo Chamber Club
Love this! Seriously cool stuff. Would be so interesting to see migration from the US as well at the same time. Sometimes a map like this can make people think they are inundated with migrants, when actually a lot of people are moving around.
Upvote (2)
Share
Max Galka
Maker
Builder of dataviz things
@alicelthwaite You're right. Despite all the recent talk about Mexican immigration, the net immigration flow with Mexico is actually negative now. When you add up all legal migration, illegal migration, and deportations in both directions, there are more people leaving the U.S. for Mexico than the other way around. It would have been great to include outbound migration in the map, but unfortunately the U.S. does not track it and the estimates I've been able to find don't go back very far.
Upvote
Share
Adam Marx
Networking consultant and music addict
I love this, both for the historical context and the mesmerizing nature of it.
Upvote (2)
Share
Max Galka
Maker
Builder of dataviz things
@adammarx13 Thank you Adam. Glad to hear you liked it.
Upvote
Share