@jsneedles@rrhoover and evidently mine can't be opened or voted upon bc it was posted after the other... also I provided feedback, did you get it? It said it'd go to the maker of the product.
@jacquescrocker - how does Ryan get my feedback?
Gatekeepers ha ha. If you have a great product, it will be on PH. The community here is awesome, but like any community you need to engage with it.. Product Hunt is a curated list of the best products available. A list of everything just isn't helpful...
@danielkempe I concur. One improvement for this type of open submission could be adding categories/collections/tagging so that everything's not in one big bucket.
Report
@danielkempe I disagree, PH is littered with Wordpress themes, incremental updates to old stuf and other assorted not-product stuff like movies, shows and so on...one must stretch his imagination to call it all product
@danielkempe completely disagree (with all due respect). There is an insider aspect to PH that is known and documented. Aside from "great" being a subjective term, a product will usually only make the PH top list if submitted by a curator/insider/gatekeeper (whatever term you prefer). Products submitted to upcoming by the general community rarely make it to the top (great or not).
@callmeed@danielkempe Erik, I think that "known and documented" is an odd term to use for Product Hunt's curation process. It's been a while since I checked the FAQ, so I'm not sure if it's in there, but I've heard the process discussed in numerous podcasts and interviews of the team, so it's not like there's a skeleton in the closet.
That being said, I hear you on the "insider" aspect. The invitation process could easily lead to cronyism, or to power-pandering invites. However, I have been very impressed by Product Hunt's consistent attempts to give voice to underrepresented groups in the tech world. For example, early on, they reached out to me and gave me five invitations, asking that I please give them out to women who would become great members of the community. (Note: I'm not the best curator, I think only 2/5 are active. 😅 But that gave me a strong appreciation for how hard it is to do this sort of thing.)
I'm not saying I'm against greater openness, but I do have faith in the team to adjust over time. And if anyone needs a reminder of what happens when there isn't curation, one needs only to looks at the screaming/crying/weird sexual advances that occurred during the Kevin Jonas AMA. (most of which were extremely cute, but some bordered on creepy)
@kikischirr thanks for the reply. I was referring more to posts than users and invites ... my comment was in the context of @danielkempe's statement that "If you have a great product, it will be on PH"–it's simply not true in a curated environment where only a handful of people can post to the front page. Just like there are great iOS apps that may never get featured by Apple in the App Store, the same applies here.
Take a look at these two links if you haven't already:
https://medium.com/@benjiwheeler...http://recode.net/2015/06/18/pro...
Look, I really like PH and have found valuable products there. I also understand that "you can't please all the people all the time." But good things can go bad if growth isn't handled properly.
Interesting concept. I like emoji and GIFs, does openhunt support that? 🤔
Report
@nivo0o0 These are the hard hitting questions that the PH community is not afraid to ask!
Report
Good luck!
I think people forget that Product Hunt is not an overnight sensation it took a lot of time and effort to get here.
What people see as conspiracy and exclusion is just evolution of the platform and community that you see today.
@chrismessina@mubashariqbal Copying and pasting this from their About page (https://www.openhunt.co/differences).
> Differences between Open Hunt and Product Hunt
- Open and Transparent
- Get Feedback on your product
- Audit Trail
- Community Governance
- Karma System (proposed)
- Queuing System (proposed)
In short, I think the goal is to borrow some elements that have worked on Reddit, make the code open source, and let the community drive the product roadmap directly.
This is sooo interesting. Everyone from Product Hunt will definitely leave PH and use a version that PH had 6 months ago?
PS: It doesn't work like that.
@thestefanstokic that's not what we're expecting at all. I'll still use Product Hunt. Just now there's another option, one that's tailored for the earlier stage / experimental products. Think of it maybe as a site dedicated to only "Upcoming" items (if you are into that sort of thing).
@thestefanstokic I don't think it's targeting people who use Product Hunt. More likely the people who are feeling excluded from it. If you look at the HN thread, there are a lot ...
@tarr11 Yes, I realize that it doesn't target PH community - Because they won't want to leave because they like it. There are a select number of frustrated people on HN, so yeah, they are targeting a niche that don't like Product Hunt.
@thestefanstokic@tarr11 if someone built a product for everything the HN peeps got angry about, we'd need about another five PH clones to handle the volume. 😝
@chrismessina they're not public. How they get to the makers, 0 idea. How do they know who the makers are, 0 idea. For something so open, there are a lot of questions remaining.
Product Hunt
Aggregations.io
Aggregations.io
Aggregations.io
SantaHunt
VC Puzzle
Quuu
I Code Dis
Baremetrics
WeKiki
Baremetrics
Trials Frontier
VC Puzzle
Trials Frontier
VC Puzzle
Open Hunt
Raycast
Astronomer
Slik
Open Hunt
Slik
MV Code Club
Slik
WeKiki
Raycast
Aggregations.io
Open Hunt